Skip to content
PROOF
← All lessons

Lesson 06 · 4 min read

Favorites, long shots, and why the odds have to add up

When a question has many answers, the answers share one pie.

Some questions have a list of answers: who wins the league, who wins the match, whether it's a draw. Every answer is its own market, and because exactly one of them will happen, their prices should add up to about one dollar.

Every answer is a slice of one pie. When the favourite grows, every long shot shrinks, and the slices always add up to the whole.

That gives you a free check. Add up the favorites. If the list sums well over a dollar, some of them are too expensive. If it sums under, something is cheap, or the 'other' answer is being ignored.

Long shots are where people are most often wrong in the same direction: they overpay for the thrill. Favorites are more boring and more often fairly priced. Being right on a favorite pays less, but it pays more often.

There's always an 'other' answer for anything nobody listed yet. Early in a season it's worth more than it looks.

Try this

Add the prices of the top four answers to a winner question. Compare the sum to 1. That gap is the first thing to think about.

Next lessonHow the Fed decides